I used to think "natural flavors" meant something good.
Natural = healthy, right?
Not exactly.
When I started researching ingredients for Ethos, I went down a rabbit hole on natural flavors. What I found made me realize why this term shows up on nearly every packaged food and beverage label, and why we'd never use it in our products.
Here's what you need to know.
What Are "Natural Flavors" According to the FDA?
The FDA defines natural flavors as:
"The essential oil, oleoresin, essence or extractive, protein hydrolysate, distillate, or any product of roasting, heating or enzymolysis, which contains the flavoring constituents derived from a spice, fruit or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud, root, leaf or similar plant material, meat, seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products, or fermentation products thereof."
Translation: As long as the original flavor source came from something natural (a plant, animal, or fermentation), it can be called "natural."
But here's the catch: The processing, extraction methods, and additional compounds added to stabilize or enhance that flavor? Those don't have to be natural at all.
The Problem With "Natural Flavors"
1. It's Intentionally Vague
When you see "natural flavors" on a label, you're seeing one ingredient.
But that one term can represent dozens of individual compounds bundled together:
- Flavor extracts
- Solvents (used to extract the flavor)
- Carriers (to transport the flavor)
- Preservatives (to stabilize it)
- Emulsifiers (to blend it into the product)
Companies don't have to disclose what's actually inside because "natural flavors" is a proprietary formula. It's considered a trade secret.
You think you're reading transparency. You're actually reading a placeholder.
2. "Natural" Doesn't Mean Unprocessed
Sure, the flavor might have started as a strawberry. But by the time it gets to your drink, it's been:
- Chemically extracted using solvents
- Processed in a lab
- Combined with synthetic compounds to stabilize it
- Adjusted for consistency, shelf life, and taste
The final product might be chemically identical to an artificial flavor — just derived from a "natural" source initially.
3. It Can Contain Synthetic Ingredients
Here's what most people don't know: Natural flavors can legally contain synthetic chemicals.
According to legal analysis of FDA regulations, natural flavors are allowed to include:
- Synthetic processing aids
- Artificial preservatives
- Chemical solvents
As long as the characterizing flavor comes from a natural source, the supporting ingredients don't have to be.
Why Do Companies Use Natural Flavors?
If they're so processed, why are natural flavors everywhere?
1. Consumer Perception
"Natural flavors" sounds better than "artificial flavors" on a label. It's marketing.
Studies show consumers associate the word "natural" with healthier, cleaner products — even when the ingredients are chemically similar to artificial alternatives.
2. Proprietary Protection
By hiding dozens of compounds under "natural flavors," companies protect their recipes without disclosing what's actually inside.
3. Cost & Consistency
Natural flavors allow manufacturers to create consistent taste profiles year-round, regardless of crop quality or availability. They're cheaper and more predictable than using actual fruit.
The Ethos Approach: No Natural Flavors. Ever.
When I was formulating Ethos, I had a choice:
Use natural flavors to make it taste sweeter and more familiar.
Or use actual organic fruit powders and let the real ingredients speak for themselves.
We chose real.
Here's What We Use Instead:
- Organic Goji Berry Powder — Real goji berries, dried and powdered. Rich in antioxidants and vitamin C.
- Organic Dragon Fruit Powder — Actual dragon fruit. High in magnesium and fiber.
- Organic Lime Powder — Real lime for citrus flavor and natural vitamin C.
No extraction. No lab processing. No hiding behind vague terms.
You see "Organic Goji Berry Powder" on our label, and that's exactly what it is. Goji berries. Organic. Powdered.
What This Means for Taste
I'm not going to lie: Ethos tastes different.
It's mineral-forward. Light fruit flavor. Not sweet.
That's because we're not using flavor compounds engineered to taste like strawberry lemonade or tropical punch. We're using real salt and real fruit.
Some people love it immediately. Some need a few days to adjust.
But here's what everyone appreciates: You know exactly what you're drinking.
No guessing. No research required. No hidden compounds.
How to Spot Natural Flavors on Labels
If you want to avoid natural flavors, here's what to look for:
Red Flags:
- "Natural flavors" or "natural flavorings"
- "Contains natural and artificial flavors"
- Long ingredient lists with vague terms
Green Flags:
- Specific ingredients listed: "Organic strawberry powder," "Lemon extract," "Vanilla bean"
- Short ingredient lists with recognizable foods
- Brands that explicitly state "No natural flavors"
The Bottom Line
"Natural flavors" sounds clean. But it's one of the most vague, unregulated terms in food labeling.
It can hide dozens of compounds. It can include synthetic chemicals. And it allows companies to mask what's actually in your food and drinks.
At Ethos, we don't hide behind it.
We use real ingredients. Organic fruit powders. Baja sea salt. Essential minerals.
When you read our label, you know exactly what you're putting in your body.
No decoding required.
References:
- FDA Code of Federal Regulations Title 21, Section 101.22
- Environmental Working Group: "Natural vs. Artificial Flavors"
- Food Drug Law Journal: "The 'Natural' vs. 'Natural Flavors' Conflict in Food Labeling"
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.